The mechanism of block form diversification in urban morphological transformation: Case study of grid blocks in Beijing, China
Jiankun Liu1(), Atsushi Deguchi2
1. School of Architecture, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300072, China 2. Graduate School of Frontier Science, The University of Tokyo, Chiba 277-0882, Japan
Beijing is a typical traditional city in China, originating from the uniform and conventional grid plan, but transformed diversely, either on purpose or spontaneously. This research took the diversification process of grid blocks as an angle to understand the transformation process of Beijing’s urban morphology. It took 194 grid blocks within the 3rd Ring Road of Beijing as research objects. First, the paper proposed a whole view of Beijing’s grid blocks by 1) visualizing their construction process, 2) classifying 5 morphological clusters by 7 indicators (Block size, Block shape regularity, Intensity, Coverage, Network density, Plot shape regularity, Standard deviation of plot size), and 3) investigating their distribution. Second, the diversification process of grid blocks was clarified from two layers: the block-boundary layer and the inner-space layer. Finally, the mechanism of block form diversification was clarified by exploring the connections between elements in each layer, and the influence of urban development on block form transformation. The study re-defined the diversification process in a more quantitative way from both time and spatial dimension. It concluded that the diversification is influenced by changes in urban planning principles and locations, and emerged thorough the long-term transformation and resubdivision. The interaction between the boundary and the inner space stimulates the diversification. And based on these, it concluded with a discussion of limitations and potentials on grid blocks’ construction and renovation.
. [J]. Frontiers of Architectural Research, 2024, 13(4): 928-943.
Jiankun Liu, Atsushi Deguchi. The mechanism of block form diversification in urban morphological transformation: Case study of grid blocks in Beijing, China. Front. Archit. Res., 2024, 13(4): 928-943.
R. Arai,, T. Kubo,, K. Ohnishi,, 2008. A study on the present condition and the problems for townscape conservation and reconstruction. In: Historic Areas in Beijing Old City, China, Journal of the City Planning Institute of Japan, 2008, Volume 43, the Annual Conference of the City Planning Institute of Japan, p. 92.
2
D. Bray,, 2005. Social Space and Governance in Urban China: the Danwei System from Origins to Reform. Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA.
3
R. Collins, George, Collins, Christiane Crasemann, 1965. Camillo Sitte and the Birth of Modern City Planning. Random House, New York.
4
Y. Deng,, S. Funo,, 1999 A study on the formation and the transformation of street blocks in Cao-Yang-Men district, the old inner city in Beijing. Journal of Architecture and Planning (Transactions of AIJ) 64 (Issue 526), 175- 183
5
G. Dong,, 1996 Sishiqi Nian de Guanghui Licheng-Jianguo Yilai Beijing Chengshi Guihua de Fazhan. (Forty-Seven Years of Glorious History-The Development of Urban Planning in Beijing since the Founding of the People’s Republic of China). Beijing Planning Review (5), 5- 8
6
G. Dong,, 2006a Wushiqi Nian de Guanghui Licheng-Jianguo Yilai Beijing Chengshi Guihua de Fazhan. (Fifty-Seven Years of Glorious History-The Development of Urban Planning in Beijing since the Founding of the People’s Republic of China). Beijing Planning Review 13- 16, 05.
7
G. Dong,, 2006b. The 50-year Evolution of the Ancient Capital. Dongnan University Press, Beijing.
8
M. Fujikawa,, H. Tanimura,, S. Watanabe,, 2002. Spatial order of a traditional neighborhood in the FENG-SHENG district of Beijing. J. Archit. Plann. Environ. Eng. 555, 145- 150. AIJ.
9
X. Ge, B. Hausleitner,, 2017. A Typomorphological Study of Chinese Superblock. Proc. Of the 24th International Seminar on Urban Form (ISUF). Valencia. ISUF.
10
P. Groth,, 1981 Streetgrids as frameworks for urban variety. Harv. Architect. Rev. 2, 68- 75
11
M. Kawai,, S. Nishide,, S. Funo,, 2015. Study on the spatial formation and transformation of Xin-tai-cang district of old inner castle in Beijing vol.1: block formation and street system. Summaries of Technical Papers of Annual Meeting. Architectural Institute of Japan..
12
S. Kostof,, 1991. The City Shaped: Urban Patterns and Meanings through History. Little, Brown, Boston.
13
J. Leite,, R. Justo,, 2017. Typo-morphology: from research to architectural education. In: Architectural Research Addressing Societal Challenges, Proceedings of the EAAE ARCC 10th International Conference. CRC Press, Lisbon, Portugal. Boca Raton.
14
H. Liu,, 2018. Research of the Morphological Types of Superblocks in the Old City of Nanjing. Southeast University, Nanjing.
15
J. Liu,, 2013. Integrating and Weaving--“Chang’an street-the three gate street” urban design.. In: Beijing Old City. Tsinghua University.
16
W. Liu,, W. Fu,, Y. Wu,, B. Xue,, S. Wang,, 2016 Urban image research in Dongsi historical street, Beijing. Planners 32(S2), 224- 229
17
S. Muratori,, 1959. Studi per un’operante storia urbana di Venezia (Iconic morphological study on Venice). Istituto Poligrafico dello Stato, Roma.
18
M.B. Pont, P. Haupt,, 2009. Space, Density and Urban Form. Technique University of Delft, Delft, pp. 199- 206.
19
Q. Sheng,, 2012 Distribution logic of local public space: a spatial configuration analysis on the local shops inside 222 urban blocks in the third ring of Beijing. Urban Planning International 27 (6), 61- 68
20
Q. Sheng,, X. Liu,, Zh Yang,, 2016 Expanding shopping spaces in the informational age: empirical study on the morphology of shops in Beijing’s central city area. Urban Design 4, 74- 81
21
Y. Shi,, X. Sun,, 2023 Characteristics, mechanisms and response strategies of multi-scale divergence in Beijing’s historical and cultural districts from a socio-spatial perspective. Beijing Planning Review 2, 48- 53
22
L. Sun,, Y. Zhou,, X. Sun,, P. Yang, Zh, An,, 2022 Beijing yanshou street: a study on spatial form renewal strategy of historical neighborhood based on space Syntax theory. Beijing Planning Review 3, 119- 123
23
M. Tang,, 2000. Beijing Old City ’Urban Text. Tsinghua University.
24
C. Webster,, J. Ruan,, G. Sun,, 2017. Private gains and social costs of China’s gated communities. In: Watanabe, Y. (Ed.), Hand-book of Cultural Security.
25
Z. Wen,, Y. Zhang,, Y. Tao,, X. Zuo,, 2019 Study on urban fabric and spatial form in Beijing’s Core area. Beijing Planning Review 4, 150- 156
26
F. Xue, X. Liu,, 2014. Beijing: from Traditional Capital to the Chinese World City. Social Sciences Academic Press (China), Beijing.
27
Y.J. Zhao,, 2011 Institutional genes of city style. Time Architecture 3, 12- 15
